Skip to main content

How to select an integration solution(ESB) for your enterprise IT

If you are an IT architect responsible for designing your enterprise IT system, you may have already experienced this topic. Modern IT systems consists of so many different systems developed by different vendors with different technology stacks. Even though those are developed independently, those systems should interact with each other to provide a seamless business experience to your stake holders. This is where the challenge of integration comes into the picture. Integrating heterogenous systems is a very complex task and you need to consider so many things before choosing a proper solution. With this blog post, I am going to discuss about the things which you need to consider when choosing an integration solution for your enterprise. I have grabbed some ideas from the following blog post[1] which also describes a similar topic.

[1] http://www.infoq.com/articles/ESB-Integration

Mainly, there are 2 streams of product categories available in the market.


  1. Open source software
  2. Proprietary software
Following table describes the capabilities of these 2 different streams of products with respect to the facts which we need to consider when choosing an integration solution.


Fact to be considered
 Open Source
 Proprietary



Usability
 Easy to install in few minutes
 Complex installations sometimes require consultants to install

Supports most operating systems
 Good documentation

Easy to play around and explore features
 High memory footprint and considerable learning curve

Low memory footprint




Maintainability and Monitoring
 Administration and Monitoring capabilities are not up to the level of proprietary solutions
 Powerful visual tools for admin and monitoring which are integrated to the solution



Community
 Open source community around respective projects 
 Less or zero free community

Own community with lot of free information in terms of blogs, articles, tutorials
 Buy support and you get access to forums and other information



Enterprise support
 Most of the open source companies earn money by providing support
 Pay more and get good support

Support is provided by engineers who develop the code (WSO2)
 If you pay less, then you have to do most of the things by going through forums

Quick and customer friendly support




Flexibility
 Provide customizations pretty quickly
 Hard to get features and take more time (even years)

Quick bug fixes
 If you pay more, you have a chance of getting earlier



Functionality
 May lack some features
 Concrete set of features

Always improving and improving quickly
 Stable releases with fixed road maps



Extensibility
 Easy to extend with clear extension points
 Do it yourself or pay more and get new components/products

Your custom code has same privileges as internal code (WSO2)




Connectors
 Fully or partially free connectors
 Full set of connectors which you need to buy ($$$)

Supports most of the important applications




Costs
 Low and decent pricing
 More and more. May increase when the project goes on



Licensing
 Business friendly (Apache2) and transparent licensing
 Complex price list which is hard to understand till you are charged

Pay for what you want 


No hidden fees




Vendors
 WSO2, Fuse ESB, Mule ESB, Talend ESB, AdroitLogic ESB, Apache ServiceMix
 Oracle ESB, IBM Websphere, Tibco, Microsoft BizTalk, SAP NetWeaver PI, Progress Sonic

According to your requirements and budget, you can go for either open source or proprietary solutions. 

Labels:

Comments

  1. PriyaDecember 18, 2019 at 2:51 AM

    Thanks for sharing this blog.The article you provided here about"How to select an integration solution(ESB) for your enterprise IT" gives lot of information.
    Mulesoft Online Training
    Mulesoft Training in Hyderabad

    ReplyDelete
  2. bhanuDecember 24, 2021 at 1:59 AM

    Thanks for sharing valuable blog.
    ServiceNow Training in Ameerpet
    ServiceNow Training

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

WSO2 ESB tuning performance with threads

I have written several blog posts explaining the internal behavior of the ESB and the threads created inside ESB. With this post, I am talking about the effect of threads in the WSO2 ESB and how to tune up threads for optimal performance. You can refer [1] and [2] to understand the threads created within the ESB. [1] http://soatutorials.blogspot.com/2015/05/understanding-threads-created-in-wso2.html [2] http://wso2.com/library/articles/2012/03/importance-performance-wso2-esb-handles-nonobvious/ Within this blog post, I am discussing about the "worker threads" which are used for processing the data within the WSO2 ESB. There are 2 types of worker threads created when you start sending the requests to the server 1) Server Worker/Client Worker Threads 2) Mediator Worker (Synapse-Worker) Threads Server Worker/Client Worker Threads These set of threads will be used to process all the requests/responses coming to the ESB server. ServerWorker Threads will be used to pr...
4 comments
Read more

How puppet works in your IT infrstructure

What is Puppet? Puppet is IT automation software that helps system administrators manage infrastructure throughout its lifecycle, from provisioning and configuration to orchestration and reporting. Using Puppet, you can easily automate repetitive tasks, quickly deploy critical applications, and proactively manage change, scaling from 10s of servers to 1000s, on-premise or in the cloud. How the puppet works? It works like this..Puppet agent is a daemon that runs on all the client servers(the servers where you require some configuration, or the servers which are going to be managed using puppet.) All the clients which are to be managed will have puppet agent installed on them, and are called nodes in puppet. Puppet Master: This machine contains all the configuration for different hosts. Puppet master will run as a daemon on this master server. Puppet Agent: This is the daemon that will run on all the servers, which are to be managed using p...
7 comments
Read more

Understanding Threads created in WSO2 ESB

WSO2 ESB is an asynchronous high performing messaging engine which uses Java NIO technology for its internal implementations. You can find more information about the implementation details about the WSO2 ESB’s high performing http transport known as Pass-Through Transport (PTT) from the links given below. [1] http://soatutorials.blogspot.com/2015/05/understanding-wso2-esb-pass-through.html [2] http://wso2.com/library/articles/2013/12/demystifying-wso2-esb-pass-through-transport-part-i/ From this tutorial, I am going to discuss about various threads created when you start the ESB and start processing requests with that. This would help you to troubleshoot critical ESB server issues with the usage of a thread dump. You can monitor the threads created by using a monitoring tool like Jconsole or java mission control (java 1.7.40 upwards). Given below is a list of important threads and their stack traces from an active ESB server.  PassThroughHTTPSSender ( 1 Thread ...
2 comments
Read more